Understanding Breach of Trust in Asset Management
What you should know

In the complicated dance of personal and professional relationships, trust forms a touchstone upon which fiduciary relationships are based. The rupture of such trust may propagate shadows not only across personal terrains but also legal ones. This present article explores the breach of trust concerning the consequences attendant upon its occurrence, common situations where it occurs, and the legal approaches taken in such cases.
We will explain with interesting practical examples what violation of trust and serious repercussions mean in respect of a criminal breach of trust.
Violation of Trust meaning
In essence, the breach of trust commensurates upon believing that a fiduciary-a person or entity with a vested interest in trust has become derelict from duty in an action, not by legal and ethical order that, therefore, violates the trust vested upon him by another party, usually a beneficiary. In its very nature, the tenor of this relationship/bond exhibited here is asymmetric: this fiduciary is to manage other parties, often with sensitive financial information or other personal details.
Importance of Understanding Breach of Trust
It is important to understand the subtlety of a breach of trust for several reasons:
- Protection of Interests: Beneficiaries should be notified about their rights so that they will be able to duly protect them against any potential violation.
- Accountability is exhibited by holding fiduciaries accountable for their actions and encourages a climate of integrity and, thus, transparency.
- Legal action: The knowledge regarding present legal frameworks, as well as protection, aids individuals to be decisive in cases of breaches.
Breach of trust examples
Breaches of trust can happen on a wide range of levels. Following are several common breach of trust examples to show how these violations can occur:
Mismanagement of Trust Assets
The quintessential example is where a trustee mismanages the assets of the trust through poor investment choices or in a manner unbeknownst to the terms of the trust. For instance, if a trustee were to decide to invest the corpus of the trust in highly risky investments without disclosing the same to the beneficiaries, then he or she could be found liable for breach of their fiduciary duties.
Under the California Probate Code § 16000, a trustee has been under obligation to manage a trust solely for the benefit of beneficiaries, with the highest loyalty and care possible.
Trustee Acting Outside Authority
A trustee is supposed to stay within the scope of his authority. If he exceeds this authority-for instance, where he enters contracts that are primarily for his benefit instead of the principal’s-he is held liable for breach of trust. This could become a heavy financial loss and even a loss of reputation for the principal.
Financial Advisor Misconduct
Another classic example of a breach of trust takes place in the course of financial advisory relationships. When a financial adviser places his interests, earning commissions from certain products above the needs of his clients, he is in breach of trust. The financial consequences, and hence loss to the clients, can be huge and could have largely been avoided had there been proper advice.
Key elements of breach of trust
Before one can determine whether there has been a breach of trust, there needs to be an understanding of what basic fiduciary duties a trustee or fiduciary owes. These are the linchpin duties underlying a fiduciary relationship that define what is expected of the fiduciary to act in the best interest of the beneficiary.
Understanding Fiduciary Duties
The fiduciary duties can be further segmented into several critical components:
Duty of Loyalty
Of first rank is the duty of loyalty, whereby there is imposition on fiduciaries to act, without conflict of interest, solely for the benefit of their beneficiaries. If an attorney is handling a case for a client, for example, he should not enter into any business transaction that might be advantageous to him at the expense of his client.
Breach of this duty may have important legal repercussions, such as possible awarding of damages to the injured party.
Duty of Care
It means that fiduciaries will have to apply appropriate active care and competence in the decision-making process, for example, when a trustee is under obligation to deal with the assets under trust diligently and carefully, making relevantly informed decisions in the best interest of the beneficiaries. Whoever fails to do so shall be held liable for a claimed breach of trust by way of restitution of losses for such breach.
Duty of Good Faith
Fiduciaries shall deal in good faith; complete candor needs to be directly reflected in the transaction. One party shall furnish information accurately and without semblance of deceit to the beneficiary. Breach of good faith will lead to the collapse of the trust and come along with serious legal consequences.
The Duty of Confidentiality
It involves the duty of confidentiality binding a fiduciary from disclosing confidential information about the beneficiaries or the trust. As such, an advisor, for example, dealing with investments cannot disclose the financial status of the clients unless given consent by such clients. Data Breach violates this confidence and may result in some legal consequences.
Breach of Trust Legal Consequences
Legal action will follow these steps.
- Filing a Breach Claim: Beneficiaries can seek legal remedies upon a breach of confidence: A claim for breach of trust could normally be instituted by filing an action, the stages for which are as under:
- Proof of Evidence: Documents, correspondences, and any other forms of information that can substantiate the criminal breach of trust will be collected. It could be financial records, a trail of emails, or minutes of meetings where decisions were taken.
- Obtaining Professional Legal Advice: Employ a lawyer specializing in trust and estate litigation to review the case and provide legal advice to the beneficiary. Legal advice may be effective as specific guidance according to the particular laws of fiduciary relationships.
- Proving Causality in Cases: In cases involving criminal breach of trust, it is the establishment of causation that stands paramount. Beneficiaries should therefore show and prove that the direct implication of breach by the fiduciary resulted in their harm or loss. This usually calls for expert testimony and careful investigation of books of account. Evidence is primarily needed by courts to make such a claim good by showing that such actions by the fiduciary resulted in certain damages that were suffered by the beneficiary.
Consequences of criminal breach of trust
The after-effects of this breach can be pretty serious and are also likely to include :
- Restitution: The court may order the fiduciary to pay restitution for losses incurred by beneficiaries due to the breach. The amount of restitution usually pertains to what a beneficiary loses financially as a direct result of the fiduciary’s actions.
- Loss of Fiduciary Privileges: In some cases, a fiduciary who is found guilty of a breach may lose that position and the privileges such a position bestows. A loss of this kind may spill over into affecting professional reputation and even career opportunities in the future.
- Possible Criminal Charges: Fraud or even embezzlement charges, heavy fines, and imprisonment are seemingly underlying aspects in the most extreme cases. The legal consequences of criminal breach of trust can be deep, touching upon even professional standing and personal life.
Hess-Verdon Commitment
You are important to us!
From the moment you call and fill out the form, you will receive courteous and prompt attention.
Call us today.
Common Fiduciary Relationships
Fiduciary relationships come in many shapes and sizes, with varying responsibilities and implications depending on the nature of the relationship. Some common examples include:
Trustee and Beneficiary
One of those relationships is that of a trustee and beneficiary. Trustees are to manage the assets of the trust per the terms outlined in the trust for the benefit of the beneficiaries. Under California Probate Code § 16000, a trustee shall administer the trust solely in the interests of the beneficiaries, with the highest standards of loyalty and care.
Agent and Principal
With agency relationships, the agent acts in place of the principal in financial or lawful matters. The agent is to act in the best interest of the principal in accountability and transparency. An agent is obliged to endorse and deliver the instrument. If an agent fails to do so, they may be liable for any resulting damages.
Board of Directors
Corporate boards ultimately owe fiduciary duties to the shareholders, consisting of care and loyalty. Under California Corporations Code § 309, directors must act in good faith and in a manner they believe to be in the best interests of the corporation.
California Corporations Code § 309 provides that “a director shall perform their duties in compliance with this chapter, in good faith, and in a manner believed by that director to be in the best interests of the corporation.” A breach of these aforementioned duties could result in lawsuits by shareholders and other resultant financial damages in large measure.
Addressing the criminal Breach of Trust
The faster the breach of trust is dealt with, the less harm there will be for others, and the sooner one can restore trust. This may entail retaining the services of an attorney specializing in trust and estate issues.
A scholar on this particular subject matter will help guide the beneficiary through filing a claim and court procedures, with their rights duly protected in the process.
An informed attorney may help beneficiaries to fathom the intricacies that might relate to their case and, subsequently, the consequences pertaining to them.
How to troubleshoot criminal breach of trust
- Investigation: The necessary investigation is to be carried out, which would help in ascertaining the facts relating to the breach. This may require interviewing witnesses or scrutinizing financial documents.
- Documentation: Gather all the necessary documents, like emails, contracts, and financial records, which substantiate this claim. Proper documentation will be essential in proving the case of breach.
- Mediation/Arbitration: Perhaps alternative dispute resolution methods can resolve this issue amicably without going to court. Often, mediation provides a quicker and less adversarial solution that saves relationships and saves money.
- Litigation: Where the mediation yields undesirable results, lawfully prepare for court by filing a case against the fiduciary on the grounds of breach of trust. This will entail presenting evidence before the court and proving how the fiduciary breached his obligations.
The Role of Mediation and Arbitration in breach of trust cases
Mediation and arbitration are especially indicated in trust disputes. Mediation offers the parties the opportunity for open discussions with the aim of settling, without going to the courts. Arbitration involves a neutral third party deciding on the issue; it is usually binding upon the parties. The advantages are saving of time, and legal expenses, and more often than not, both parties benefit more from the outcome.
Summary
Breach of trust has wide ramifications among parties involved, having massive potential consequences on personal relationships, financial stability included. In this area of fiduciary relationships, both fiduciaries and beneficiaries should understand what the nature of fiduciary duties entails, common scenarios leading to their breach, and legal implications. Transparency, accountability, and ethical conduct will maintain and protect trust in these very important relationships.
Beneficiaries are generally in a much better position to protect themselves against any potential breaches in piles when they understand the meaning of the breach of trust and their rights. This makes the responsibility of a trustee, agent, or corporate board a very cardinal issue. The legal frameworks do exist to provide force for these duties to ensure fiduciaries act in tandem with what is in the interest of those they serve.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a breach of trust?
There is a breach of trust when a fiduciary fails in his duties and causes the interest of the beneficiary, such as trust which he has placed in him, to be violated.
What are the fiduciary duties?
Fiduciary duties refer to legally binding, imposed obligations on a fiduciary to act not in their interest but rather to best serve their principals or beneficiaries concerning expected standards of loyalty, due care, good faith, and confidentiality.
What are the legal implications of a breach of trust?
Other legal consequences include financial restitution, loss of fiduciary privileges, and possible criminal charges, depending upon the severity of the breach.
Who typically holds fiduciary relationships?
Fiduciary relationships are normally held by trustees, lawyers, agents, and members of the board.
How can breaches be addressed?
Legal consultation is also a venue to resolve breaches, the investigation included and even going into litigation to seek restitution on damages incurred.
Can I sue for a breach of trust?
Yes, you can, provided you can prove there was a criminal breach of fiduciary duty and that you have suffered damages from the breach.
Other topics of interest
Do you need your case reviewed? When it comes to the practice of trust and estate matters, it can be difficult finding an attorney that’s experienced in handling your specific issues. We are here to help.
Meet The Team
How Do You Sue a Trustee of a Trust? What to Consider!
How Do You Sue a Trustee of a Trust? Use an Expert Trust Litigator Suing a trustee of a trust can be a complicated and challenging process. We provide an overview of the steps involved in suing a trustee, including understanding the grounds for suing, the legal...
Trust Litigation Attorney Fees: What You Need to Know
Trust Litigation Attorney Fees Trust litigation can be intricate and daunting, often requiring the guidance of a skilled attorney. When engaging a trust litigation attorney, it's important to consider the costs involved. This article will explore various fee...
Falsely Accused of Undue Influence – What to Understand
Falsely Accused of undue influence As a trustee, your role in managing and overseeing an estate plan is essential. You are entrusted with the responsibility of ensuring that the testator's wishes are carried out, and their assets are protected. However, in some cases,...