Get a Consultation

Hess-Verdon & Associates

Call us Today

Trustee- Protect The Estate &Amp; Your Position From Litigation

Trustee – Protect the Estate & Your Position from Litigation

As a trustee, when you understand your role and responsibilities, you can identify actions that are and are not in accordance with your fiduciary duties. When you act in accordance with your position, you can defend the trust and your position against allegations.

Call 1-888-318-4430

We are ready to hear your case

Here are key reasons to choose Hess-Verdon & Associates:

  • 30+ Years of Experience in trust, estate, probate, and real estate law.
  • Comprehensive Services: Trust/probate litigation and administration.
  • Client-Focused: Protecting trustees and beneficiaries with expert guidance.
  • Aggressive Representation to defend your legal rights.
  • Expert in Complex Trusts like undue influence and fiduciary disputes.
  • Peace of Mind: Efficient and effective counsel.
Protect Your Estate and Secure Expert Counsel
Ready? Fill out the form below and we will call you shortly.
Please enable JavaScript in your browser to complete this form.
Name

by | Oct 24, 2023

As a Trustee, How Do I Defend Against Allegations Of Breach?

You’re responsible for managing and preserving your trust’s assets as a trustee. You should work with a trust attorney to clearly understand what’s expected from you in this role so that if someone accuses you of something, you can defend against it. Here are some common scenarios:

a.) Allegations of conflict of interest 

When a trustee has been accused of a conflict of interest, they may feel unfairly judged and startled by this accusation-and understandably so! But before the panic, know this: until proven, without doubt, conflict-of-interest allegations are not grounds for removal as trustee under California law.

There are steps you can take if you believe that someone has defamed or slandered you by making these accusations; however, they will likely require patience and persistence.

Using trust funds for personal gain

As a trustee, you can’t use trust funds for personal expenses. For example, charging your kids’ private school tuition on the trust account is not okay. Nor is charging any other kind of personal expense like clothing or gasoline. The beneficiaries expect the money to be used in their best interest and not for the benefit of a trustee.

If you’re accused of misusing trust money, make sure you have documentation showing that everything you did was for the benefit of the beneficiary.

Keep detailed records from start to finish-everything from your communications with beneficiaries about their concerns to receipts for any money spent on their behalf should be available in case someone accuses you later on down the road!

In addition, keep careful track of what’s been done with which assets. This is so everything is clear between what’s supposed to happen under California trust laws versus what happens when someone complains later on down the road.

b.) Allegations of lack of communication

Lack of communication is one of the most common allegations in trust litigation. It’s also one of the easiest to defend against since you have plenty of procedural tools. The first thing you should do when a beneficiary accuses you of a lack of communication is to consult with your trust attorney. Your attorney will usually be able to tell if there is any merit to the claim, and they can help develop a plan in the future regarding communicating with beneficiaries and other parties involved in trust litigation.

If there is no immediate reason or benefit associated with contacting a beneficiary (like informing them about an upcoming distribution), it may not be worth doing so immediately. Instead, it might be more beneficial for you and the beneficiary if you wait until closer to that date before getting in touch again-it could avoid further disputes down the line regarding whether or not something was communicated correctly!

c.) Allegations of lack of transparency

As a trustee, you are required to be transparent. In California, transparency means that the person giving the gift must know what their assets are being used for. People often accuse trustees of not being transparent because they don’t understand how their trust works or how their assets will be used.

If your beneficiaries accuse you of a lack of transparency in California, there are a few things that you can do:

  • Produce evidence( of communication) that they know what their assets are being used for and why – this is one way to solve issues around lack of transparency
  • Show how you’ve always kept them informed on new laws or changes in the law.
  • Consult an attorney if necessary (an attorney may be able to help you defend yourself against allegations of lack of transparency)

Always remember that as a trustee, you should not use trust funds for trustee-owned businesses. You may only use trust funds for trustee-owned companies if they are related to the terms of the trust. That’s because, in California, it is unlawful for trustees to engage in self-dealing transactions when a trustee uses trust property for personal gain or interferes with another’s right to benefit from a trust.

It doesn’t matter how much money is involved in these transactions; any amount can trigger an investigation by California’s Department of Justice (CalDOJ). And since they have more resources than you do, it will be difficult to defend yourself against allegations of violating California’s self-dealing laws without help from an attorney who knows what they’re doing.

If you’ve been accused of using trust funds for your benefit or helping yourself at the expense of others, do not panic! Contact us today, and we’ll help you fight against these accusations using California law. Call 949-706-7300.

d.) Allegations of self-dealing

Self-dealing is using trust assets for personal benefit, and it’s a breach of fiduciary duty. The trustee must act in the best interest of the beneficiaries, not themself.

Whether or not these allegations will hold up in court depends on whether they can prove three things:

  • That there was an actual breach.
  • That there was no legitimate reason for the transaction.
  • Whether any harm came as a result of this transaction.

You can defend yourself by showing that either:

  1. No actual breach occurred (e.g., someone had access to funds but did not take them)
  2. There was a legitimate reason why money or property was used or..
  3. Even if harm did come from misusing trust assets-was it severe enough to justify the particular sanctions against you? (Again, speak to a trust litigation attorney!)

e.) Allegations of breach of fiduciary duty

You will likely be accused of breaching your fiduciary duty as a trustee. This means that the beneficiary says you did something that goes against the terms of their trust agreement. A fiduciary relationship is one in which one party (the trustee) must act in another party’s interests. They (the beneficiary) don’t have any liability or responsibility for what happens during their relationship with each other.

When heirs accuse you of breaching your fiduciary duties as trustee-you can point out that your actions were always in line with your responsibilities as a trustee. If that’s the case, your activities were always done at the grantor’s or testator’s direction and wishes.

Let’s look at an example:

Let’s say there are two siblings named John and Jane who have been fighting over their grandfather’s estate since he died ten years ago. As part of his will, Grandpa left $500k worth of stocks from his life insurance policy plus an additional $100k inheritance on top of those stocks if either sibling ever married before age 40. Otherwise, both would get half when either reached 40 years old.

If neither sibling got married by age 40, everything was split equally between both siblings after death taxes were paid off first. Breaking this amount between these siblings is not a breach of fiduciary duty.

f.) Allegations of misappropriation of trust funds

The most common allegations against trustees of trust funds are misappropriation of trust property, breach of fiduciary duty, and fraud. Trustees are responsible for the management of trust assets. They must ensure that all parties involved in managing the funds act according to California law.

As a trustee, you should protect yourself from liability by documenting all actions taken on behalf of your beneficiaries or clients. You should also be aware of the laws governing trust funds, so you can demonstrate compliance with these laws to successfully defend against any claims brought forth by beneficiaries or clients.

If a beneficiary or client has accused you of misappropriating trust funds, you must hire an experienced trust litigation attorney. A lawyer familiar with California probate codes can help guide you through this challenging process while protecting your rights during litigation proceedings.

g.) Allegations of undue influence

The accused must prove that they did not exert undue influence on any beneficiary. You can do this by presenting evidence that the actions were based on sound financial judgment and legal advice from the trust attorney.

You also must show that you made decisions without regard for personal gain at the expense of others. A plaintiff must prove these allegations beyond a reasonable doubt. Thus, it is difficult to win these cases against trustees unless there is evidence of wrongdoing, such as illegally profiting off trust assets during their tenure as trustees.

Do not transfer assets without the consent of all beneficiaries. This can be tricky when a beneficiary does not have a financial interest in the trust property. But if you have already transferred it, you will need their approval.

Next, make sure you have a valid reason for the transfer. If there are no good reasons and your transfer was undervalued or without consideration (without any compensation), your trustee status could be revoked. Finally, ensure that your trustee status permits this kind of action and that there aren’t any restrictions on what types of transfers would be considered improper for trusteeship purposes.

If a beneficiary accuses you of improper transfers, get legal advice immediately so as not to jeopardize yourself further down the road by entering into an agreement that could later hurt your case. The best way we know how is through California trust laws designed specifically for these situations.

We know that it can be hard to defend against allegations. But with the correct information, you can. There are many different ways to approach this problem, depending on your unique situation and what you want. That being said, we hope we’ve given you some helpful tips.

As A Trustee, How to Respond To the Removal from a Trust

As a trustee, you should know the grounds for removal. You may also be thinking about how to defend yourself if a beneficiary files a petition seeking your removal.

What are the grounds for a trustee removal?

There are two main ways for a trustee to be removed from a trust. First, if the trustee is incapacitated or lacks mental capacity and cannot perform their duties, the court can fire them.

Second, if convicted of a crime related to the trust, they can be removed by petitioning the court. If you are accused of these things, it’s best to talk with an attorney as soon as possible so they can help defend your rights.

Further grounds for trustee removal

The trustee can be removed from a trust if they are not acting in good faith. A trustee not acting in good faith may be removed from office and replaced with a successor trustee.

In addition, the court may remove a trustee if they are not acting in the trust’s best interest or complying with its terms. In some cases, you may need to show that your removal petition was filed before any beneficiaries took preliminary action against you to prove your case.

Furthermore, California courts have also held that trustees are required to act in accordance with their fiduciary duties and according to law when making decisions related to their position as trustees or when acting outside of their positions as trustees.

You may be removed if the terms of the trust state that the trustee may be removed for cause by the beneficiary or beneficiaries. Also, a court can remove a trustee if he has been found to have breached his fiduciary duty. This could include misappropriating funds or failing to follow instructions concerning managing trust assets.

A court may also order removal in cases where there has been an irreconcilable conflict between the beneficiaries and trustees.

What can a trustee do if they are wrongfully removed from the trust?

If you are a trustee who has been wrongfully removed from a trust, you will have several options available to challenge the removal. If the beneficiaries acted improperly or negligently in removing you as trustee, then one of the most common legal challenges is to file a lawsuit against them.

You can also file suit against their attorney if they prepared or assisted with drafting any documents involved in the removal process. A trustee may also appeal to the court of appeals if they wish to have their case heard before another judge by filing a request with that court. Before you are ever removed, contact a trust litigation attorney or get a second opinion.

How to challenge the trustee removal case

You can challenge trustee removal by showing that you have always acted in good faith and with the best interests of all beneficiaries at heart. One way to do this is to provide evidence that you have consulted with beneficiaries and acted under the grantor’s wishes at all times.

You can also show that your actions comply with trust terms or prove that you worked on behalf of underage beneficiaries. Lastly, if applicable, prove that your actions align with state laws related to trusts.

In a nutshell, if you are a trustee and feel that your removal from the trust is unjustified, there are several steps you can take to fight it. First, consider whether there are grounds for challenging the petition by your successor.

If so, file a motion to dismiss with the court and ask for a hearing as soon as possible. It is important to note that this process can be time-consuming and expensive. Therefore, it is best to have an experienced attorney who can help guide you through each step.

How to Prevent a Beneficiary from Removing a Trustee from a Trust

When you set up a trust, consider whether the beneficiary can remove the trustee. If you leave instructions for your trust that allow the beneficiary to remove a trustee, the court will follow those instructions. However, if your instructions need to be clarified, the court will decide who can remove a trustee based on who has authority over the trust assets.

A beneficiary’s right to remove a trustee is not always beneficial for everyone involved. If you want to prevent your beneficiary from removing a trustee from your trust, here are some things that you can do:

Name an independent co-trustee

The trustee should not be related to the settlor or beneficiary. The trustee should also be financially capable of managing the trust. This means that they should have enough money to cover any losses that might occur, as well as living expenses.

The trustee should not engage in self-dealing.

A trustee should never engage in self-dealing, any action that benefits them personally rather than the trust itself. This includes making purchases for their benefit, investing in ventures that may profit them personally, and making loans to family members or friends for personal use.

Include a clause in the trust that prohibits trustee removal, i.e., add a terrorem clause.

If you want to prevent someone from being able to remove a trustee from a trust, then you can include a clause in your trust document that prohibits it from happening.

If this happens anyway (for example, if you’re incapacitated or otherwise unable to make decisions), then it will be up to the courts to decide whether or not removing a trustee was appropriate under these circumstances.

The trustee should not act as an agent for anyone other than the settlor.

The trustee should not act as an agent for anyone other than the settlor. In other words, the trustee should not be involved in any transaction involving the trust’s assets other than to perform their duties under trust law. The trustee is not bound by any fiduciary duty to exercise independent judgment when making decisions concerning the trust’s assets.

What Are The Fiduciary Duties Of A Trustee, And How To Fulfill Them?

The duty of loyalty. The trustee must act in the best interest of the beneficiaries. The trustee must make decisions based on what is fair and best for all beneficiaries, not just one or two.

The duty of prudence. The trustee must manage trust assets prudently, meaning with care and caution. They should not take unnecessary risks with trust assets but invest them wisely and seek professional assistance if necessary.

The duty of good faith. The trustee must act in good faith towards the beneficiaries and perform their duties honestly and faithfully without self-dealing or conflicts of interest.

Honor requests from beneficiaries

A trustee should honor reasonable requests by any beneficiary legally entitled to make them (for example, a request for accounting).

Do not discriminate between beneficiaries.

A trustee cannot favor one beneficiary over another; all beneficiaries must receive their shares under the terms of the trust agreement (or as ordered by a court).

Do not blend trust and personal assets.

The trustee should not use trust funds to pay personal expenses. It is important to avoid commingling because it can be hard to tell where the money comes from and when it is used.

For example, you can use your money or ask for a loan against your account if you want to buy a new car. If you use trust funds, it may be difficult to explain how they were spent later if someone asks about them.

Act as a prudent person would act

The trustee should act in the best interests of the beneficiaries rather than for their benefit or convenience. He should manage assets carefully to maximize returns without taking unnecessary risks. This will help ensure that the beneficiaries receive their share when the trust ends or terminates.

Have an understanding of trust laws and regulations

You may have heard about some rules governing trusts in your state or country, but many others apply only to certain kinds of trusts or estates. You should be aware of these laws so that you do not violate them inadvertently while administering your trust.

Conclusion

If you are a trustee or will be in the future, you must comply with the trust terms and the state trust laws. This will limit the scope for lawsuits and ensure any trustee business’s smooth running. We hope this article has been educational and informative. Don’t hesitate to contact us if you want to speak to our trustee attorneys. Call our attorneys today at 1-888-318-4430.

Do Trustees Get Paid: What To Look Out For

Do Trustees Get Paid: What To Look Out For

Do Trustees Get Paid Trustees usually get paid either an hourly rate or sometimes a percentage of the trust assets. As a trustee, it's crucial to keep a detailed log of all your activities, including timeframes and tasks, to ensure that you receive full reimbursement...

Trustee As Sole Beneficiary: Implications And Responsibilities

Trustee as Sole Beneficiary: Implications and Responsibilities

Can a Trustee Be the Sole Beneficiary of a Trust? Losing a loved one can be challenging, and navigating the complexities of trust and probate law can add to the stress. You might be wondering, "Can a trustee be the sole beneficiary of a trust?" In this article, we'll...

What Trustees Can’T Do To The Estate: Know Your Rights

What Trustees Can’t Do to the Estate: Know Your Rights

What a Trustee Cannot Do A trustee must abide by the trust document and the California Probate Code. They are prohibited from using trust assets for personal gain and must act in the best interest of the beneficiaries. Trust assets are meant for the benefit of the...

Defending A Trust Contest In California With Probable Cause

Defending a Trust Contest in California With Probable Cause

Defending a Trust Contest in California Understanding Trust Contests What is a Trust Contest? A trust contest is a legal challenge against the validity of a trust or its terms. Trust contests are often initiated by disgruntled beneficiaries or individuals who believe...

Trustee Accused Of Breach Of Fiduciary Duty – What To Do

Trustee Accused of Breach of Fiduciary Duty – What to Do

Trustee Accused of Breach of Fiduciary Duty What to do! A trustee is one of the most challenging roles under the law. Property owners, known as settlors or grantors, establish trusts to put assets under the oversight of a neutral third party for beneficiaries....

Toxic Siblings After Their Parents’ Death

Toxic siblings after their parents’ death

Toxic siblings after their parents' death Siblings are not legally entitled to inheritance unless both parents are deceased. Inheritance rights may also be validated when the surviving spouse is incapacitated. Circumstances surrounding inheritance rights depend on...

RECENT POSTS

Who Has More Rights a Trustee or the Beneficiary

Who has more Right, a Trustee or the Beneficiary? Trustee vs. Beneficiary Rights: A trustee can override a beneficiary's request if it conflicts with the law or the terms of the trust. This authority is outlined in California Probate Code §16000, which mandates...

Top Orange County Probate Attorney

Top Orange County Probate Attorney When navigating the complexities of estate management, an Orange County probate attorney becomes your indispensable guide. Your peace of mind hinges on expert legal support during these intricate proceedings. With stakes this high,...

What To Expect From A Probate Attorney

What to Expect from a Probate Attorney in California In simple terms, probate is the legal process of administering an individual's estate posthumously. The courts review the will if there is any present, and in the absence, the courts will still decide on the best...

How Does A Trust Work. What to Know!

How Does a Trust Work? A trust is essential in ensuring that your assets are protected and that their distribution after you die is organized. Trusts are critical aspects of estate planning. A trust refers to a legal agreement where the trustor or settlor conveys...

How to Get A Copy of A Trust Document

How To Get A Copy of A Trust Document Have you wondered if your trustee is required to issue you a copy of the trust, and do you know what to do if they decline to provide you a copy of the trust? Here's an answer to these and other questions you might have on how to...

Hess-Verdon

JOIN HESS-VERDON CHARITABLE GIVING PROGRAM

We are excited to be able to offer 501(c)(3)’s the ability to accept charitable remainder trusts
Learn more about receiving trust donations.

ADDRESS

Hess-Verdon & Associates, PLC
620 Newport Center Drive Suite 1400
Newport Beach, California, 92660
Office: (949) 706-7300 
Toll Free: (888) 318-4430

Copyright © 2022 Hess-Verdon, PLC. All rights reserved. The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship. The verdicts and settlements listed on this site are intended to be representative of cases handled by Hess-Verdon & Associates, PLC. These listings are not a guarantee or prediction of the outcome of any other claims. The information contained on this website is not tax or legal advice and is not a substitute for such advice. State and federal laws change frequently, and the information in this article may not reflect your own state’s laws or the most recent changes to the law. For current tax or legal advice, please consult with an accountant or an attorney.